Publicly notified resource consents
Resource consent application - Taumatatotara Wind Farm Limited (RM200019)
To hear and decide the application by Independent Hearing Commissioner, a hearing commencement date has been set as follows:
Date: 13th and 14th November 2023
Time: 9.00am
Venue: Les Munro Centre, 8 King Street East, Te Kuiti
Summary of the proposal
Waitomo District Council has received an application from Taumatatotara Wind Farm Limited for a resource consent as follows:
- An application to vary conditions 1, 2, 3 and 11 of the 2008 resource consent granted to Ventus Energy (NZ) Ltd to construct a 22 turbine wind farm with tip heights of 110 metres. The wind farm site is located at Taumatatotara West Road, Te Kuiti.
- The proposal includes:
- Reducing the number of turbines from 22 to 11 (Conditions 1 and 2), including reducing the on-site roading proposed. The proposal is to retain the northern 11 turbines (in the same locations as turbines 1-11 in the original consent).
- Increase the tip height of the remaining 11 turbines from 121.5 m to 172.5m, with rotor diameter increasing from 110m to 155m.
Public notices
Public notice - Taumatatotara wind farm 23-3-23 (PDF 76 KB)
Public notice - Taumatatotara wind farm-Summary (PDF 76 KB)
Application
Taumatatotara AEE June 2020 (PDF 771 KB)
Attachment 1 - Wind Energy Yield Prediction (PDF 414 KB)
Attachment 2A - Appendix 2 V90 Transport Manual (PDF 1.09 MB)
Attachment 2B - Appendix 4 -Specialist Transporter, Windblade adapter (PDF 1.42 MB)
Attachment 2C - Transport Memorandum -3 July 2020 (PDF 1.09 MB)
Attachment 3 - Turbine Dimensions (PDF 355 KB)
Attachment 4 - Civil Aviation email (PDF 1.78 MB)
Attachment 5 - Noise Assessment Altissmo Consulting (PDF 593 KB)
Attachment 6A - Landscape and Visual Assessment, WPS Opus (PDF 900 KB)
Attachment 6B - Landscape Graphic Attachments (PDF 2.56 MB)
Attachment 6C - Photographic Equipment (PDF 113 KB)
Attachment 7 - Ecology Memorandum (PDF 115 KB)
Attachment 8 - Landowner's full names (PDF 399 KB)
Attachment 9 - 2008 Consent Conditions Waitomo District Council (PDF 1.54 MB)
Attachment 10 - Opus Landscape Visual Assessment S92 Response 2012 (PDF 1.62 MB)
Attachment 11 - ZVI Analysis (PDF 1.7 MB)
Attachment 12 - Response re Mansergh Graham Memo Dec 2019 (PDF 599 KB)
Attachment 13 - Ngā Tai o Kāwhia Communication (PDF 364 KB)
Further information request pursuant to section 92 of the Resource Management Act 1991
1_WDC_Section 92 request for further information RM200019 (PDF 234 KB)
2_Applicant response (PDF 246 KB)
Appendix 1 - LVEA (WPS Opus) (PDF 862 KB)
Appendix 1B - Landscape Graphic Attachments (PDF 2.71 MB)
Appendix 2 - Noise (Altissimo Consulting) (PDF 521 KB)
Appendix 3A - Ecological Areas map (PDF 1.09 MB)
Appendix 3B - photos road, turbine sites (PDF 1.02 MB)
Appendix 3C - SNA's near T4 Windfarm Map (PDF 271 KB)
Appendix 4A - Avifauna (PDF 310 KB)
Appendix 4B - Bats (Ecology NZ) (PDF 455 KB)
Appendix 5 - Transportation Response (TES Ltd) (PDF 4.51 MB)
Appendix 6 - 2004 Ecological report (PDF 932 KB)
Appendix 7 - 2005 Ecological report turbines 18-22 (PDF 1.29 MB)
Further information response from the Applicant
1_WDC L006 Further info clarification 3_Feb_2021 (PDF 156 KB)
1_WDC to Ventus - L007 Further information clarification 11_May_2021 (PDF 576 KB)
2_Clarification letter to Waitomo DC (PDF 74 KB)
2_S92 Clarification letter (PDF 102 KB)
Ecology Memorandum 10.4.21 (PDF 423 KB)
Ecology Report 10 Aug 21 (PDF 1.49 MB)
Email_ Taumatatotara WF conditions (PDF 154 KB)
Landscape and Visual Assessment WSP 22 March 2021 (PDF 1.11 MB)
Memorandum WSP re visual landscape (PDF 1.11 MB)
Ngaati Mahuta response to Taumatatotara wind farm turbines (PDF 229 KB)
Noise letter 10 November 2020 (PDF 866 KB)
Noise Altissimo 7.4.21 (PDF 1.25 MB)
Transportation 18.2.21 (PDF 190 KB)
Notification Decision and Report
s95 Notification Decision - RM200019 (PDF 260 KB)
s95 Notification report - Taumatatotara 17_Sept 2021 (PDF 16.9 MB)
Submission form
Application history
RM050019 – decision on the original application (PDF 3.6 MB)
RM050019A – section 127 application to change consent conditions (PDF 1.26 MB)
Submissions
Chris Iron & Debra Hastie (PDF 1.92 MB)
David Galbraith (PDF 168 KB)
Department of Conservation (PDF 230 KB)
Julie Knight & Brett Knight (PDF 159 KB)
Leslie Gaston (PDF 252 KB)
Natasha Willison (PDF 250 KB)
Ngahuia Herangi (PDF 151 KB)
Roimata Harmon (PDF 188 KB)
Susan Irons (PDF 2.71 MB)
Te Nehenehenui (PDF 499 KB)
Te Nehenehenui - 2 (PDF 591 KB)
Trustees of John David Keepa Kupa Whaanau Trust (PDF 301 KB)
Virginnia Dawn Taia (PDF 412 KB)
Waikato regional Council (PDF 195 KB)
Yvonne Armstrong (PDF 1.37 MB)
Summary of Submissions (PDF 48 KB)
Further information requested as a result of submissions
Hearing Direction, Notices and Minutes
Hearing Notice (PDF 168 KB)
Minute 1 – 12 September 2023 (PDF 84 KB)
Minute 2 – 14 September 2023 (PDF 16 KB)
Minute 3 – 19 September 2023 (PDF 21 KB)
Minute 4 – 2 October 2023 (PDF 74 KB)
Minute 5 - 3 October 2023 (PDF 112 KB)
Minute 5 - Reissue 4 October 2023 (PDF 116 KB)
Legal Submissions
S42A Report and Appendices
S42A Report Taumatatotara Windfarm RM200019 (No Appendices) (PDF 432 KB)
S42A Report Taumatatotara Windfarm RM200019 (with Appendices) (PDF 17.67 MB)
Appendix 1 - 2006 Decision (PDF 249 KB)
Appendix 2 - 2011 Variation Decision (PDF 12.53 MB)
Appendix 3 - WRC Consent (PDF 606 KB)
Appendix 4 - Summary of Submissions (PDF 53 KB)
Appendix 5 - Landscape and Visual (PDF 404 KB)
Appendix 6 - Noise (PDF 252 KB)
Appendix 7 - Ecology (PDF 650 KB)
Appendix 8 - Traffic-Transport (PDF 1.19 MB)
Appendix 9 - Separation Distance Map (PDF 687 KB)
Appendix 10 - Applicant's Draft Conditions (PDF 82 KB)
Appendix 11 - S42A Report Draft Conditions (PDF 90 KB)
Appendix 12 - Notification Decision (PDF 224 KB)
Applicant’s Evidence and other Documents
Taumatatotara Windfarm Waitomo DC Evidence ENZL Final (PDF 420 KB)
Taumatatotara Windfarm Waitomo DC Summary Statement Evidence ENZL (PDF 112 KB)
EIC Glenn Starr (Corporate) Final (PDF 686 KB)
Evidence t4 - Michael Smith Acoustics (PDF 913 KB)
Evidence t4 Transport J Daly w appendices (PDF 2.92 MB)
Evidence Mike Moore att 1 Landscape graphics (PDF 11.82 MB)
Evidence t4 M Moore Landscape inc App B (PDF 981 KB)
T4 C Shearer Planning apps 1, 2, 4, 5, 7 (PDF 1.46 MB)
App 3 Site Plan Final (PDF 692 KB)
Taumatatotara Site Plan 1.5 (A3) SNA BATS v4 (PDF 414 KB)
Appendix 3; TWF Site Plan 8.11.23 (PDF 696 KB)
App 6 Consent Conditions Hearing Version (PDF 128 KB)
Supplementary Evidence M Moore landscape (PDF 198 KB)
Taumatatotara - Overlays (PDF 3.92 MB)
Part 2-s31 Assessment TWF 14.11.23 (PDF 147 KB)
Legal submissions T4 FINAL (PDF 365 KB)
Summary Evidence Final (PDF 169 KB)
Table of Authorities (PDF 84 KB)
Table of Authorities - Legal Submissions
Body Corporate 97010 v Auckland City Council CA64 00, 17 August 2000 (PDF 106 KB)
Envirowaste Services Ltd v Auckland Council [2011] NZEnvC 130 (PDF 3.35 MB)
Genesis Power Ltd v Franklin District Council ENC Auckland A148 05, 7 September 2005 (PDF 2.22 MB)
McIntyre v Christchurch City Council PT A15 96, 5 March 1996 (PDF 901 KB)
Ngati Kahu Ki Whangaroa Co-operative Society Ltd v Northland Regional Council ENC Auckland A95 2000, 4 August 2000 (PDF 2.87 MB)
Ngati Ruahine v Bay of Plenty Regional Council [2012] NZHC 3381 (PDF 156 KB)
Palmerston North City Council v New Zealand Windfarms Ltd [2013] NZHC 2654 (PDF 51 KB)
Palmerston North City Council v New Zealand Windfarms Ltd [2014] NZCA 601 (PDF 565 KB)
R J Davidson Family Trust v Marlborough District Council [2017] NZHC 52 (PDF 2.02 MB)
R J Davidson Family Trust v Marlborough District Council [2018] NZCA 316 (PDF 291 KB)
Re Meridian Energy Ltd [2013] NZEnvC 59 (PDF 6.96 MB)
Te Runanga O Ngai Te Rangi Iwi Trust v Bay of Plenty Regional Council [2011] NZEnvC 402 (PDF 5.55 MB)
Te Runanga o Ngati Awa v Bay of Plenty Regional Council [2019] NZEnvC 196 (PDF 2.51 MB)
Wakatipu Environmental Society Inc v Queenstown Lakes District Council ENC Christchurch C164 2004, 26 October 2004 (PDF 588 KB)
Z-National-Policy-Statement-for-Indigenous-Biodiversity (PDF 533 KB)
Z-nps-reg-2011 (PDF 76 KB)
ZZ proposed-national-policy-statement-for-renewable-electricity-generation (PDF 298 KB)
ZZZ Bats and Windfarms Advice Note - Version 5 - 6 October 2023 (PDF 347 KB)
Submitter’s Evidence and other Documents
Ngahuia Herangi
Ngaati Mahuta ki te Hauaaruru support letter to commissioner FINAL (PDF 38 KB)
Ngaati Mahuta ki te Hauaauru effects assessment report FINAL (PDF 401 KB)
Department of Conservation
Memorandum of Counsel requesting an extension of evidence deadline (PDF 74 KB)
Evidence of M Pryde (Bat Ecology) (PDF 1015 KB)
Taumatatotara Windfarm Planning Evidence E Williams 8 November Final (PDF 434 KB)
Legal Submissions on behalf of the Director-General of Conservation (PDF 621 KB)
Decision of the Mackenzie District Council and Caterbury Regional Council re an application for a solar array at Tekapo (PDF 512 KB)
Davidson Family Trust v Marlborough District Council [2017] NZHC 52 (PDF 656 KB)
Dye v Auckland Regional Council [2002] 1 NZLR 337 (PDF 90 KB)
Environmental Defence Society Inc v New Zealand King Salmon Co Ltd [2014] NZSC 38 (PDF 584 KB)
R J Davidson Family Trust v Marlborough District Council [2016] NZEnvC 81 (PDF 5.83 MB)
Sustain Our Sounds Inc v New Zealand King Salmon Co Ltd [2014] NZSC 40 (PDF 208 KB)
- IMG_4425 (MP4 20.27 MB)
Environment Court Practice-Note-2023- 10.4 - draft conditions (PDF 292 KB)
Summary Statement Moira Pryde_ (003) (PDF 226 KB)
Taumatatotara Windfarm Supplementary Planning Evidence E Williams final (PDF 220 KB)
Track changes version of the amended legal submissions on behalf of the Director-General of Conservation (PDF 632 KB)
Amended Legal submissions on behalf of the Director General of Conservation (PDF 628 KB)
Weston Lea Ltd case (PDF 1.59 MB)
Julie Knight & Brett Knight
Sue Irons
Yvonne Armstrong
- C8730A51-38F3-4388-AD72-C9E8BE22F709 (MOV 2.4 MB)
Flooding Evidence Tahaaroa Road- bottom of the valley -before the quarry into Tahaaroa (PDF 95 KB)
Other Documents Presented by Reporting Officer
Draft 14 Nov S42A Report Addendum Taumatatotara Windfarm RM200019 (PDF 402 KB)
T4 Conditions 14 November hearing version (WDC version) 10.00 am (PDF 351 KB)
Post Hearing Information
Reporting Officer
Report To Hearings Committee for Taumatatotara windfarm.doc (2006) (PDF 249 KB)
Schedule 6 - submission points on SNA provisions - PWDP (PDF 83 KB)
Waitomo PDP Submissions - T4 (DoC evidence) (PDF 1.12 MB)
s42A Report Ventus s127 (Final) (PDF 12.53 MB)
Taumatatotara DoC submission 2006 (PDF 141 KB)
T4 Conditions post hearing WDC version 24 November (FINAL for Commissioner) (PDF 275 KB)
Appendix 1; TWF Site Plan 8.11.23 (PDF 696 KB)
T4 Conditions post hearing WDC marked up 30.11.23 (FINAL) 5.00 pm version (PDF 115 KB)
Appendix 1 - TWF Site Plan 8.11.23 (PDF 696 KB)
T4 Conditions post hearing WDC marked up 30.11.23 (FINAL) 5.00 pm version + Appendix (PDF 846 KB)
Department of Conservation
Supplementary Legal Submissions on behalf of the Director-General of Conservation (PDF 740 KB)
T4 Conditions post hearing WDC version 24 November 3pm (FINAL for Commissioner) With DOC tracked changes 8pm (PDF 426 KB)
Applicant
Legal submissions T4 Reply Submissions (PDF 329 KB)
Aubade NZ Ltd v Marlborough District Council [2015] NZEnvC 154 (PDF 1.55 MB)
DL Newlove Ltd v Northland Regional Council PT Decision A30 94, 27 April 1994 (PDF 118 KB)
Dye v Auckland Regional Council CA86 01, 11 September 2001 (PDF 58 KB)
Meridian Energy Ltd v Wellington City Council ENC Wellington W031 07, 14 May 2007 (PDF 4.98 MB)
NZ Rail Ltd v Marlborough District Council HC Wellington AP169 93, 4 November 1993 (PDF 912 KB)
R J Davidson Family Trust v Marlborough District Council [2016] NZEnvC 81 (PDF 5.83 MB)
Sampson v Waikato Regional Council ENC Auckland A178 2002, 2 September 2002 (PDF 486 KB)
Shirley Primary School v Christchurch City Council ENC C136 98, 14 December 1998 (PDF 2.4 MB)
Decision
Decision Report - Taumatatotara Wind Farm s127 Application FINAL (PDF 1.37 MB)